Mayday
  • ACTUS
    • Actualités du marché
    • Deals
    • Base des deals
    • Interviews
    • International
    • Recrutements
    • Evènements
  • PORTRAITS
  • ECLAIRAGES D’EXPERTS
    • Articles
    • Podcasts
  • ENTREPRISES A REPRENDRE
    • Plateforme d’appels d’offres d’entreprises et d’actifs à reprendre
    • Rapports hebdomadaires des ouvertures de procédures collectives et des appels d’offres
  • ANNUAIRES
    • Community / Experts
  • PODCAST CAPITAINE
  • NOTRE CONCEPT
  • MAYDAY MAG
  • CONNEXION
  • S’ABONNER
  • NOTRE CONCEPT
  • MAYDAY MAG
  • CONNEXION
  • S’ABONNER
Mayday
  • ACTUS
    • Actualités du marché
    • Deals
    • Base des deals
    • Interviews
    • International
    • Recrutements
    • Evènements
  • PORTRAITS
  • ECLAIRAGES D’EXPERTS
    • Articles
    • Podcasts
  • ENTREPRISES A REPRENDRE
    • Plateforme d’appels d’offres d’entreprises et d’actifs à reprendre
    • Rapports hebdomadaires des ouvertures de procédures collectives et des appels d’offres
  • ANNUAIRES
    • Community / Experts
  • PODCAST CAPITAINE
0
  • ACTUS

#Interview : What is the current situation of businesses in Spain after the outbreak of coronavirus?

  • 16 avril 2020
José Carles

As Spain was one of the countries that was first hit by COVID-19, it was also one of the first to adopt measures. The state of emergency (estado de alarma) was declared almost a month ago (March 14), and it implied the lockdown that many other countries have also implemented in the past weeks. To make this lockdown possible, non-essential and outdoor-activity related businesses were obliged to close. Initially, for two weeks. Then, for two more weeks. Now, two more weeks, and the President of the Spanish government has already announced that he foresees at least two additional weeks. This means that many businesses — hotels, restaurants, apparel retailers, etc.— will be closed for at least two months. In addition, while businesses obtain no cash income for two months, they still need to pay their fixed-costs, creating critical tensions in the businesses’ cash flows. In this context, Mayday has interviewed José Carles, co-managing partner of CARLES CUESTA, a Spanish law firm based in Madrid renowned in restructuring & insolvency, which intervenes also in corporate transactions, international M&A, litigation, international arbitration and public law. 

Mayday: What measures have been taken to help Spanish companies under difficulties because of COVID-19?

José Carles: In the insolvency field, Royal Decree 8/2020, of March 17, on urgent extraordinary measures to deal with the economic and social impact of COVID-19 included temporary insolvency-related measures. The main measure was to suspend the obligation to file for insolvency while the state of emergency persists (therefore, after the successive extensions, at least until April 26).

In my opinion, this measure is a huge mistake although I understand why it was adopted. In Spain, directors may incur in civil liability if they do not comply with their obligation to file in time (two months), so the government was afraid that almost every Spanish company would have not complied with this obligation and would have faced liability issues.

However, this measure brings the attention towards avoiding liability with no further action, which is indeed an issue, but secondary, as it does not really help businesses to recover —the primary goal—.

Mayday: Are many insolvencies expected in the near future in Spain?

JC: In Spain, as in many other countries, there is a stigma associated to insolvency proceedings. Therefore, many businesses avoid it until there is nothing to do. This stigma, the uncertainty regarding the duration of the lockdown measures (and, therefore, regarding the future of the company’s activity itself) and the fact that many companies feel they are doing enough by taking measures such as collective temporary redundancy schemes (ERTEs) or by requesting additional ICO financing, will delay many insolvency filings.

Spanish law

In fact, in the very short term, only the most financially sophisticated debtors (those who take an American Chapter 11 approach, with no shame) are exploring the possibility to file. They understand that they have outstanding payments that they cannot meet and that, even if the insolvency filing is not compulsory in this very moment, it is the right thing to do.

Most of Spanish businesses, however, will take a decision once the state of emergency ceases, when they feel they are in a position to evaluate the real damage caused to their business by the coronavirus pandemic. In the months of May and June, I would say.

We just missed an excellent opportunity to educate businesses in the timely use of our insolvency proceedings (concurso de acreedores) and its out-of-Court alternatives as a true restructuring tool. The American way.

Mayday: What measures would you have suggested to the Spanish legislator?

JC: We actually have contacted the government with our recommendations. There is nothing wrong with insolvency proceedings and therefore there is no need to suspend the obligation to file. This only incentivizes the stigma associated to insolvency which we are trying so hard to leave behind.

What is wrong is to make use of insolvency proceedings only as a last resource. As it is highly recommended that people check their health when they have early symptoms of any illness, companies should address their liquidity issues at an early stage —this is actually one of the goals of the recent Directive on preventive restructuring frameworks—. Suspending the obligation to file is like educating companies in not visiting the doctor when they find they have a lump. It does not make sense.

If the solution is then within filing for insolvency proceedings, the relevant issue is in the approach to the insolvency proceedings itself. As insolvency proceedings still are regarded as a problem, why not approach the problem with a solution such as early arrangements with creditors (propuestas anticipadas de convenio)?

These measures are, actually, what we recommended to the government. Early arrangements with creditors imply much quicker proceedings, a higher rate of trust among creditors (as the debtor approaches the problem with a specific solution from the very beginning) and, therefore, a much higher degree of success of the insolvency proceeding as a restructuring tool. We have prepared many insolvency proceedings four our clients at CARLES CUESTA with an early arrangement with creditors and they are very successful.

Mayday: How can these early or anticipated arrangements with creditors be incentivized?

In these COVID-19 times, early compositions could be incentivized by temporarily eliminating the requisite to file them with the support of any creditors that amount at least to 10% of the total company’s liabilities. Or by avoiding the opening of the side proceedings where the liability of directors is analyzed (pieza de calificación) if an early arrangement with creditor is filed with the petition itself, under certain conditions.

Incentivizing these anticipated solutions in the proceedings would decrease the workload of the Commercial Courts. This would result in Commercial Courts being able to handle a higher number of proceedings at the same time with no delays.

Mayday: What about pre-pack sales? Would they be a solution under Spanish law?

Our Insolvency Act does not foresee pre-pack sales like in other countries (UK). Nevertheless, the insolvency filing in Spain can include a binding offer for the business unit (venta de unidad productiva) with a limited period of validity to try to speed up the sale of the business unit during the initial phase of the insolvency proceedings (fase común). It still takes a while and needs the authorization of the Commercial Court, but it is much preferred to sales in other moments in which much of the company’s value will more likely have been destroyed.

Mayday: Do you expect any further amendments of the Spanish Insolvency Act in the near future?

JC:  A few days ago, the Spanish Council of Ministers requested the urgent opinion of the State Advisory Council on the pending project of the Spanish Insolvency Act Recast (proyecto de texto refundido de Ley Concursal). The State Advisory Council should have delivered their report by now.

However, it is widely understood that it is not the moment to create unnecessary uncertainty by passing a new law. Therefore, the most convenient approach would be to take further temporary measures adapted specifically to the extraordinary circumstances derived from this pandemic such as the ones I just suggested.

Interview by Cyprien de Girval

 

Article précédent
Guillaume Bordier
  • ACTUS

#Eclairage : Coronavirus, quelles mesures de protection des salariés ?

  • 15 avril 2020
Lire l'Article
Article suivant
La Halle
  • ACTUS

#Actu : La Halle sollicite l’ouverture d’une procédure de sauvegarde

  • 16 avril 2020
Lire l'Article

Laisser un commentaire Annuler la réponse

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *

Ce site utilise Akismet pour réduire les indésirables. En savoir plus sur comment les données de vos commentaires sont utilisées.

DECOUVREZ MAYDAY ASSETS
Reprise d'entreprises
Dernières dépêches
    avatar @bymaydaymag
    RT @EtudeMeynet: AJ MEYNET & ASSOCIES cherche des repreneurs pour une activité de traiteur restaurant et boutique située à Lyon 7°. DLDO :…
    10 days ago
    • Reply
    • 2 Retweet
    • Favorite
    Follow
    Rejoignez-nous sur Facebook
    Étiquettes
    Actus AJ Associés Analyses Appel d'Offres BCLP BFR expertise & solutions Bird & Bird BruzzoDubucq Capitaine CORHOFI Coups de coeur Darrois Deal Deloitte Eclairages Enthoven & Girard Entreprises à reprendre Equitis event Evènement EY Franklin Gibson Dunn GM associés Goodwin Initiatives International Interviews KPMG Le saviez-vous Linklaters Mayday Assets Mayday Drink Mayday Morning Paul Hastings Podcasts Pono Portraits Racine Rebonds Recrutement Spark Veille Veilles Vivien&Associés
    MAYDAY
    • Abonnements et Tarifs
    • Nous contacter
    • Mentions légales
    • CGV/CGU
    • Mayday Events
    • Studio Graphique
    • Mon compte
    La plateforme web du retournement des entreprises

    Input your search keywords and press Enter.

    Mayday Mag utilise des données non sensibles comme des cookies pour vous offrir une expérience utilisateur de qualité, mesurer l’audience et optimiser les fonctionnalités des réseaux sociaux.
    En poursuivant votre navigation sur ce site, vous acceptez l’utilisation de cookies dans les conditions prévues par notre politique de confidentialité. Vous pouvez modifier vos préférences à tout moment en revenant sur ce site.
    Accepter En savoir plus
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Toujours activé
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    Enregistrer & appliquer